Apple Tries to Stifle Free Speech, Gets Hit With Lawsuit Instead
Apple, the company behind the Mac OS X, the iPhone and iPod Touch is getting sued – again. This time it is not over the multi-touch technology used with the iPhone, it is over legal threats the company made. It seems that Apple asked OdioWorks, company that runs the BluWiki website, to take down posts related to iTunes workarounds; OdioWorks ignored Apple’s cease-and-desist letter which invoked the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and decided to fight for the freedom of speech by suing Apple.
Sam Odio, owner of OdioWorks comments: “I take the free speech rights of BluWiki users seriously. Companies like Apple should not be able to censor online discussions by making baseless legal threats against services like BluWiki that host the discussions."
The whole issue appears to have been spurred by Apple’s decision to prevent iPhone and iPod Touch users from using media management software other than iTunes. The discussions focused on how you could enable your iPhone and/or iPod Touch so that you could use media management software such as Winamp and Songbird, not iTunes. Apple of course did not take kindly to this and invoked copyright interests in the matter – to which the EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) responded by saying they are not copyright interests, but censorship attempts.
“Apple's legal threats against BluWiki are about censorship, not about protecting their legitimate copyright interests. Wikis and other community sites are home to many vibrant discussions among hobbyists and tinkerers. It's legal to engage in reverse engineering in order to create a competing product, it's legal to talk about reverse engineering, and it's legal for a public wiki to host those discussions, commented Senior Intellectual Property Attorney with the EFF, Fred von Lohmann.
It should be noted that BluWiki, at the time of receiving Apple’s cease-and-desist letter complied and took down the discussions (which by the way did not get as far as to constitute development of a way to bypass iTunes), but now would like to get legal cover so as to continue those discussions.
Tags: Apple, Lawsuit, BluWiki, OdioWorks, Censorship, EFF
Sam Odio, owner of OdioWorks comments: “I take the free speech rights of BluWiki users seriously. Companies like Apple should not be able to censor online discussions by making baseless legal threats against services like BluWiki that host the discussions."
Advertising
The whole issue appears to have been spurred by Apple’s decision to prevent iPhone and iPod Touch users from using media management software other than iTunes. The discussions focused on how you could enable your iPhone and/or iPod Touch so that you could use media management software such as Winamp and Songbird, not iTunes. Apple of course did not take kindly to this and invoked copyright interests in the matter – to which the EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) responded by saying they are not copyright interests, but censorship attempts.
“Apple's legal threats against BluWiki are about censorship, not about protecting their legitimate copyright interests. Wikis and other community sites are home to many vibrant discussions among hobbyists and tinkerers. It's legal to engage in reverse engineering in order to create a competing product, it's legal to talk about reverse engineering, and it's legal for a public wiki to host those discussions, commented Senior Intellectual Property Attorney with the EFF, Fred von Lohmann.
It should be noted that BluWiki, at the time of receiving Apple’s cease-and-desist letter complied and took down the discussions (which by the way did not get as far as to constitute development of a way to bypass iTunes), but now would like to get legal cover so as to continue those discussions.
Tags: Apple, Lawsuit, BluWiki, OdioWorks, Censorship, EFF
I Hope you LIKE this blog post! Thank you!
What do YOU have to say about this
blog comments powered by Disqus
Popular News
By George Norman on 10 Feb 2012
With the release of Wolfram|Alpha Pro, the team behind the popular computational knowledge engine took a very big step forward
By George Norman on 10 Feb 2012
Microsoft has just announced that this February, as part of the Patch Tuesday program, it will roll out a grand total of 9 security bulletins to all customers all over the world.Related News
By George Norman on 09 Sep 2011
The first news in this article is that HTC, the Taiwanese manufacturer of smartphones, filed a lawsuit against Cupertino-based software developer Apple, claiming that Apple is infringing on several of its 
By George Norman on 09 Sep 2011
Former COO (Chief Operations Officer) and current CEO (Chief Executive Officer) of Apple Tim Cook showed his philanthropic side in an email sent out to all Apple employees. The letter announces the introduction of a
By George Norman on 10 Oct 2011
Word on the web has it that Japanese multinational conglomerate corporation Sony purchased the rights to turn Steve Jobs’ biography into a movie. It is yet unclear how much Sony paid for the movie rights
By George Norman on 13 Dec 2011
Just like Google, Apple is celebrating the fact that people are downloading apps from its app stores. The Cupertino-based software developer announced that more than 100 million downloads have been served via its Mac App StoreAdvertising
Hot Software Updates
Top Downloads
2.
Opera5.
Trillian8.
AIM9.
Skype10.
Ad-Aware12.
Nero13.
Google Earth14.
Picasa15.
Winamp16.
iTunes17.
RealPlayer18.
uTorrent19.
eMule20.
WinRAR21.
BitComet22.
WinZip23.
Shareaza24.
CCleaner25.
Recuva26.
Tweak UI27.
CuteFTP Home29.
Adobe Reader30.
NewsPiperBecome A Fan!
Link To Us!
Apple Tries to Stifle Free Speech, Gets Hit With Lawsuit Instead
HTML Linking Code
HTML Linking Code